By Scott Taylor
For months now, the greater Canadian defence community has been almost giddy at the prospect of the hundreds of billions of dollars allocated to future defence budgets.
Organizations have sprouted up and begun hosting hastily organized seminars and conferences, while simultaneously, the ranks of Ottawa lobby firms have been swollen with new hires, all promising to guide industry newcomers through the maze-like process of Canadian defence procurement.
The expectation from all involved is that very soon there will be a huge boatload of money being spent on future weapon systems, and everyone is jockeying to get in on the ground floor. There is no question that huge investments are necessary to replace almost everything in the Canadian military's current combat cupboard.
However, on the flip side of that equation is the fact that the Canadian Armed Forces are still gripped by a crippling shortfall in personnel. What will be the point of buying hundreds of billions of dollars worth of new high tech weapon systems if there is no one in uniform left to operate them?
Last year the CAF reported a large increase in the number of new recruits, however, delays in training cycles and the unsuitability of many of those recruited has meant that little progress has been made towards filling a shortfall of nearly 16,000 personnel from an authorized regular and reserve combined strength of 105,000.
That has not stopped the senior military and Department of National Defence officials from thinking even bigger. In May 2025, Chief of Defence Staff General Jennie Carignan and then Deputy Minister Stefanie Beck collaborated together on a nine page mobilization plan for Canada.
In October of 2025, Ottawa Citizen reporter David Pugliese obtained a copy of that unclassified document and the revelations were startling.
The dynamic duo of Beck and Carignan envisioned growing the existing Primary Reserve from 23,561 to a staggering 100,000 personnel. Even more ambitious was their plan to stand up a Supplementary Reserve force of no less than 300,000 individuals.
For those not familiar with the terms, primary reservists are enrolled in the military and are employed on a part time basis by actual formed units. The Supplementary Reserve in earlier times was a list of mostly retired military veterans who had sworn their consent to return to duty in the event of a war or national crisis.
Post Cold War neglect of this list saw the number of registered supplementary reservists drop to a meagre 4,384 souls at last count.
As there is nowhere near 300,000 able bodied former military members residing in Canada, Carignan and Beck thought they could swell the ranks of the Supplementary Reserve with Public Servants. The plan was to give these 300,000 volunteers a week long training course which would involve some level of weapons handling and the operation of basic vehicles.
This rudimentary training was to be repeated on an annual basis. The Canadian Supplementary Reserve, as originally envisioned by Carignan and Beck, was not to be issued with uniforms. Presumably this was to keep down the start-up cost of this venture.
The good news for those expected to become one-week-wonders, is that little progress has been made to date on actually implementing any of this plan.
In May 2026 General Carignan was asked for an update and she told CBC news that she was finalizing recommendations for this new force and she would be prepared to present options to her political masters sometime in June, 2026.
Her claim to CBC that "rhere is a lot of interest in doing this' would seem to have been a little premature as we are midway through November and there has been no concrete development so far.
For the Primary Reserve there has been some recent movement albeit in the exact opposite direction from the Carignan and Beck plan to grow the numbers to 100,000.
A recent Ottawa Citizen headline read "Canadian Army cutting reserve military jobs, cancelling some training: The cuts come at a time of unprecedented defence spending."
According to the Citizen report, the Canadian Army is indeed reducing some reserve force training exercises and more surprisingly cutting reserve jobs.
To add insult to injury many of those affected reservists who had contacted the Citizen had been advised of their termination just days before Remembrance Day. A number of them were half way through what they had believed to be a one year, full-time Class B contract. They were simply notified they would be released within 30 days.
In response to the Citizen, Department of National Defence spokesperson Laura McIntyre-Grills confirmed that such layoffs were being made. "Ultimately, the overall available Reserve pay allocation within the Army is being directed toward the highest readiness priorities,” McIntyre-Grills noted in an email. “In effect, the Army is reducing activities that have been deemed to be lower priority, including some locally authorized temporary Class B employment positions, and some individual training days or short-duration training exercises (2-to-9-day training events) may be reduced in scope or cancelled.”
Honestly folks this is a dumb as the time the Three Stooges began drilling additional holes in the bottom of their sinking boat in order to let the water out. A CAF that is starved for personnel and facing a choke point in the training system is actually laying off reservists and cancelling short term training exercises in order to concentrate on readiness?
Do they honestly think that personnel having a contract suddenly cancelled will be willing to come back with another offer of a Class B contract?
These jilted reservists will not only steer well clear of future offers, they will also tell anyone who will listen not to trust a job in the reserves. At this rate the Primary Reserve will never see the lofty dream of 100,000 personnel.
The patriot in me offers this suggestion for free to General Carignan. If you want 300,000 Canadians to register for your Supplementary Reserve add a tax credit incentive on income tax returns. If you sign a declaration that in time of national emergency you will volunteer to serve, Canada Revenue Agency will give you a $500 credit.
It used to be called 'taking the King's shilling' but allowing for the current inflation $500 could prove enough of an incentive to get them to sign on the dotted line.
